Sunday, June 9, 2013

Lesbians the United States and In Iran

About thirty years ago, I when I worked at Sikorsky Aircraft, I worked with a man who was homosexual.  At the time I had only one friend who had come out, and did not know anyone who in the work place felt that they could be open about their preference.  This man was no exception, he hide and lied about who he was.  I remember that he went to New Haven one evening and had his legs broken, was tossed in the trunk of a car and driven around and harassed for hours before being released.  Although this was a male and our assignment asks about women, I started with this to show how much our culture in this area of the country has changed.  Culture is fluid and I needed to remind myself of this when I started thinking about how things have changed here and how homosexuals are treated in Islamic countries. My first thought was that change could not take place in with such extreme beliefs, however perhaps it can.
Within this country we have seen many positive changes regarding the issue of homosexuality in the past thirty years.  We now have groups in high schools to create awareness of diversity, something that was unheard of thirty years ago, we have awareness events on television, radio and in other areas bringing awareness into the lives of people who may or may not have gay or lesbian friends and also to support those who are gay, lesbian or transgender.  Movies and television shows openly portray the dynamic of people and families that are “different” from what was previously considered “normal”.  This all serves to bring awareness into peoples and will lead to change.  Now I work with many people who are openly gay or lesbian.  In my state, Connecticut, you can marry.  I work with a woman who is a lesbian and is married.  She does not need to hide who she is and she is treated professionally no different because of her choice.  If you think about this, it is pretty amazing.  Tossed in a trunk and never being able to talk about whom you are, living a lie, to openly married and being able to have children together and have insurance companies acknowledge the couple with insurance coverage.  Wow.  This has been a long road for this population and is a battle that is not over yet.   In my state, a lesbian can legally marry, however that is not true across all of the states yet. Women and men still have many challenges to face before the basic human right of sexual freedom is met in this country.   I feel strongly that it is only a matter of time before that change takes place.  If I were back in time, I would have never been able to envision this time and I will reflect upon that when thinking that something will “never” change. The challenges that both women and men face will be overcome, the question is how to get there and how long with that change take. 
I have a friend whose partner is from Saudi, he is now seeking political asylum because of his sexual preference.  Can you imagine having to make the choice to leave behind your country, your family, and your friends all because you are not allowed to live peacefully in your country because of your sexual preference?  His choice would be to return and live a lie, and be miserable for his entire life or risk death if he was ever found to be homosexual.
 I found an article that addresses the challenges that people face regarding sexual preference in Islamic countries.  For this assignment, let’s look at only women and only one of the countries, Iran.  In Iran if you are found to be of sound mind and have committed a lesbian act the punishment for the first offense is 100 lashes for each of the people involved.  If the act is repeated three times, you can be put to death.  The beliefs in Iran and other Islamic countries prohibit same sex contact.  We don’t see any thought as to what the person’s personal preferences and right
because of homosexual activity and the article stated that “girls as young as 9 and boys as young as 14 can be hanged.” (Shafi’I, 13) Culture in this country does not support a woman’s personal freedoms and preferences.  Women are still treated very differently from men in regard to freedoms, although in this particular topic, they are judged and punished in the same fashion as the males.  The culture does not allow people to speak out and to work toward brining change about.  So in a case like this how can change be realized?  The road to change in a culture that has such deep roots in anti-homosexuality would need to start from outside.  I think that awareness of what life is like is a step and books written by people who have left their country behind in order to seek freedom will help people to become first more aware of what life is really like for an Iranian woman. People who have cut their ties need to actively voice their experiences via public forums to also heighten awareness.    Political changes would need to take place as well, with a leader who had focus on more freedoms.  The way the government is now, does not make me feel that change is in any way eminent.   
When we compare Iran to our country we can see that the culture in Iran does not focus on personal freedoms and human rights as a priority, whereas in this country you have the right to speak out publicly.  Change here can come faster because we can speak up.  You may risk your job, and perhaps as with my friend who was injured thirty years ago, risk some personal harm, however collectively as groups when people come together to expose a violation of their human rights the ground for change is often laid.  I am sad to say that the way change needs to take place in Iran would need to have major political changes in order for people to just be able to speak out.  Change can take place, however when and how is more difficult and complicated based on the cultural difference.   Women in this country as well as across the world need to know that they have the right to be able to be open about their sexual preferences.  We can see, however that in a country like Iran that consideration to safety and protection of life has made this impossible at this time.    

References:
Achieving Human Rights through Social Work Practice, Chapter 10, provided by Fordham University, 2013
Shafi’I Abdul Azeez Bello, The Punishment of Homosexuality In Islamic Contemporary World, Malaysia, Iran, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia as a Case Study), http://ssrn.com/abstract=2183622, retrieved 6/2013


No comments:

Post a Comment